Ask the Commish.Com

The Fantasy Advisors

     

2025 VIP Draft Kit


Table of Contents


Draft Day Advice
-General Advice
-Position Advice

-2025 NFL Schedule
-Strength of Schedule


QB Statistical Analysis
-2024 Top Performances
-2024 Most Fantasy Points
-2024 Most Avg Fantasy Points
-2024 Median Fantasy Points
-2024 Most Consistent
-Easiest 2025 Schedule
-Easiest 2025 Playoff Schedule

RB Statistical Analysis
-2024 Top Performances
-2024 Most Fantasy Points
-2024 Most Avg Fantasy Points
-2024 Median Fantasy Points
-2024 Most Consistent
-Easiest 2025 Schedule
-Easiest 2025 Playoff Schedule

WR Statistical Analysis
-2024 Top Performances
-2024 Most Fantasy Points
-2024 Most Avg Fantasy Points
-2024 Median Fantasy Points
-2024 Most Consistent
-Easiest 2025 Schedule
-Easiest 2025 Playoff Schedule

TE Statistical Analysis
-2024 Top Performances
-2024 Most Fantasy Points
-2024 Most Avg Fantasy Points
-2024 Median Fantasy Points
-2024 Most Consistent
-Easiest 2025 Schedule
-Easiest 2025 Playoff Schedule

Kicker Statistical Analysis
-2024 Top Performances
-2024 Most Fantasy Points
-2024 Most Avg Fantasy Points
-2024 Median Fantasy Points
-2024 Most Consistent
-Easiest 2025 Schedule
-Easiest 2025 Playoff Schedule

2024 Defense Rankings
-Fantasy Points Allowed (Total)
-Fantasy Points Allowed QBs
-Fantasy Points Allowed RBs
-Fantasy Points Allowed WRs
-Fantasy Points Allowed TEs
-Fantasy Points Allowed Ks

Proven Draft Strategy
-Numerical Analysis
-GCAM (Overview)
-GCAM (QBs)
-GCAM (RBs)
-GCAM (WRs)
-GCAM (TEs)
-GCAM (PKs)
-GCAM (D/ST)

Targets, Carries and Touches
-2024 Most Targets
-2024 Most Carries
-2024 Most Touches

Redzone Analysis
-2024 Redzone Passing
-2024 Redzone Rushing
-2024 Redzone Receiving
-2024 Redzone Touches

Depth Charts
-AFC East
-AFC North
-AFC South
-AFC West
-NFC East
-NFC North
-NFC South
-NFC West

Nagging Injuries
-QBs
-RBs
-WRs
-TEs

Moving Truck Tracker
-QBs
-RBs
-WRs
-TEs

Rookie Report
-QBs
-RBs
-WRs
-TEs
-PKs
-Dynasty/Rookie Snapshot

Sophomore Status
-QBs
-RBs
-WRs
-TEs
-PKs

Fantasy Studs
-QBs
-RBs
-WRs
-TEs
-PKs
-D/ST

Sleepers
-QBs
-RBs
-WRs
-TEs
-PKs
-D/ST

Duds
-QBs
-RBs
-WRs
-TEs
-PKs
-D/ST

Average Draft Position
-Top 150
-QB
-RB
-WR
-TE
-PK
-D/ST
-DL
-LB
-DB

ATC Cheat Sheets
QB Rankings
RB Rankings
WR Rankings
TE Rankings
PK Rankings
Team Defense/Special Teams Rankings
DL Rankings
LB Rankings
DB Rankings
Draft Board Snapshot
Top 200 Players Overall
Top 216 Auction Values

MOCK DRAFT

Ask the Commish.Com
2025
Draft Kit

QB 2nd Year Players

 

Maye, Drake - NE

Maye, Drake

Drake Maye might not have moved the needle for fantasy in his rookie season, but his performance over 12 starts was impressive considering how terrible his supporting cast was. From Week 6 of last season, when Maye made his first start, through Week 17, Maye averaged a respectable 16.8 fantasy points per game. The third overall pick in last year's NFL Draft, Maye has immense potential as a passer, but it's his rushing that should make him attractive to fantasy games. Maye had 421 rushing yards last season, and there's potential for much more. As a sophomore at the University of North Carolina, Maye had 698 rushing yards in 14 games. Bear in mind that college quarterbacks' sack yardage counts against their rushing yardage, and Maye lost about 200 yards from his rushing total that year. Maye should have it a little easier in the passing game this year, with New England beefing up its offensive line in the offseason and adding WRs Stefon Diggs and Kyle Williams. It's possible we get a Drake Maye breakout in 2025.


Nix, Bo - DEN

Nix, Bo

I was down on Bo Nix entering last season. Early on, it looked like I was right about my evaluation of him as a prospect. Nix STRUGGLED out of the gate before turning it on in Week 5. Once the candle was lit for Nix, he coffin nailed my evaluation of his upside in the NFL. In Weeks 5-18, Nix was the QB6 in fantasy points per game, ranking 15th in yards per attempt, tenth in CPOE, ninth in highly accurate throw rate, and eighth in fantasy points per dropback (per Fantasy Points Data). I've never been happier being proved wrong. He was nothing short of amazing and placed third in the NFL Rookie of the Year voting. He also provided rushing upside, which I didn't expect in the NFL. Last year, he ranked tenth in carries per game and eighth in rushing yards among quarterbacks. Denver added Pat Bryant, R.J. Harvey, J.K. Dobbins, and Evan Engram to this offense in the offseason. Nix could take another step in 2025 with the added weaponry and be a top-five quarterback.


Daniels, Jayden - WAS

Daniels, Jayden

Daniels was a league-winning value last year in his rookie season as the QB6 in fantasy points per game. If we remove the two games in which he failed to play more than 50% of the snaps, he averaged 23.7 fantasy points per game and had 0.61 fantasy points per dropback. Those two figures would have ranked second and fourth among quarterbacks last year. In those 15 full games, Daniels averaged 58.2 rushing yards per game, which would have led all quarterbacks last year by 4.4 yards per game. He also wasn't a pushover from the pocket, ranking 14th in yards per attempt, 11th in CPOE, and sixth in catchable target rate (per Fantasy Points Data). Daniels can improve in the passing department, though, which is incredibly scary for anyone not drafting him as he was 24th in highly accurate throw rate and 17th in off-target rate. Daniels has QB1 overall upside this season with a mid QB1 floor.


Williams, Caleb - CHI

Williams, Caleb

Caleb Williams is a polarizing figure in the fantasy community. Depending on whom you ask, his rookie season was somewhere between alarmingly poor and reasonably decent considering the headwinds into which he was sailing. The Bears' play-calling was questionable under offensive coordinator Shane Waldron, and it was hard to see improvement in that department after Waldron was fired in-season. The Bears' offensive line was a sieve, as Williams took a league-high 68 sacks. He finished with 3,541 passing yards, 20 TD passes and six INTs in 17 starts, adding 489 rushing yards but no rushing touchdowns. The Bears have diligently spruced up Williams' ecosystem, hiring highly regarded playcaller Ben Johnson as their head coach, dramatically upgrading the middle of the offensive line in free agency, and adding TE Colston Loveland and WR Luther Burden in the draft. Williams is known for his ability to make plays out of structure, but if he can start making plays *in* structure, he has a chance to take a huge leap forward in his second NFL season.


McCarthy, J.J. - MIN

McCarthy, J.J.

J.J. McCarthy missed his entire rookie season with a torn meniscus in his knee but enters 2025 as the Vikings' undisputed starting quarterback. McCarthy steps into a very healthy offensive ecosystem. Vikings head coach Kevin O'Connell is one of the NFL's shrewdest offensive architects. Justin Jefferson and Jordan Addison form a terrific WR duo, and T.J. Hockenson is a top tight end. The Vikings have a good pair of offensive tackles and upgraded the middle of their offensive line in the offseason. Things might not always go smoothly for McCarthy in his first go-round as an NFL starter, but he offers intriguing rushing upside. McCarthy had eight TD runs in his final two college seasons at Michigan.


Penix Jr., Michael - ATL

Penix Jr., Michael

Michael Penix heads into the 2025 season as the Falcons' unquestioned starting quarterback after sitting behind Kirk Cousins for most of the 2024 season. Penix did make three late-season starts, completing 58% of his throws in those games, averaging 245.7 passing yards per game and 7.4 yards per attempt, with three touchdowns and three interceptions. Penix is a pocket passer who doesn't offer much rushing upside, but he has a powerful and accurate arm. He led FBS in passing yardage in each of his final two college seasons at Washington. Penix has the potential to return a small profit on his low-end QB2 price tag.


Milton III, Joe - DAL

Milton III, Joe

Joe Milton III traded to Dallas

The Patriots have traded QB Joe Milton III and a seventh-round draft pick to Dallas in exchange for a fifth-round draft pick.

Milton has been the subject of trade rumors all offseason after he impressed in a game against the Bills to close out the 2024 season. The 25-year-old quarterback will open the season as the backup to Dak Prescott and will provide the Cowboys will a solid option should Prescott miss any time during the season.


Rattler, Spencer - NO

Rattler, Spencer

Spencer Rattler sees majority of first-team reps at OTAs Thursday

Spencer Rattler reportedly saw the majority of the first-team reps at Saints OTAs on Thursday.

Rattler went 10-of-12, which included a nice throw to Juwan Johnson on an over route & hit Chris Olave on a dig. This remains a camp battle to monitor between him and Tyler Shough.




Previous   Next

© 2025 ATC All rights reserved.